Sisters
August 5th, 2011
The Short Take:
You could call this book a crime mystery (and whether there is a crime is actually in grave doubt) and you could call it a voyage of self-discovery. It’s hard to say which aspect outweighs the other. And there’s a major twist at the end that keeps the tension going to the very last line.
Why?
There’s a lot of guessing in this book. And assumptions. And wild accusations. And those are just on the part of the main character, Bee. Written in first person, the book consists of Bee’s imagined monologue to her dead sister, Tess, explaining just how she figured everything out about Tess’ death.
The story jumps between two timelines that aren’t very far apart from each other. One traces Bee’s investigation, the other is built around her retelling of the investigation to a lawyer. As you can imagine, sometimes it’s a bit confusing which timeline you’re in, but as it all winds up in the same place, there’s really no need to worry about it.
Lupton’s book is also very much a character study of the two sisters — one who embraced all of life (and is now dead) and the other who has sought safety and security over actual living (that would be Bee). Add to this a thread of possible insanity running throughout (and we could be talking about either or both women here), and you’ve got a really solid modern gothic novel.
You’re really never quite sure where this debut novel is headed, but when it gets there — boy, what a surprise! And, it didn’t feel like a rabbit pulled out of a hat to me. The hints where there but very clever. At least, I sure didn’t suspect a thing until 20-20 hindsight kicked in.
A Little Plot:
English expat Bee races back to London when her mother reports that younger sister Tess is missing. Tess’ body is soon found and all signs point to a suicide — her wrists are slashed and she’d just had a stillborn child. But Bee is convinced that her sister would never end her own life and starts investigating every conceivable angle of Tess’ life to prove her point.
Bee uncovers a lot (the lover, the stalker, the medical procedures, the shrink), and she is glad to share every new discovery and resultant theory with investigators and doubting family members — encouraging doubts about her own mental stability.
It’s a fine mess. And I do mean fine. If you want to know more about Lupton and her book click here.








