Saturday, September 26th, 2015
The Short Take:
This novel about the loves of Queen Elizabeth I, written by a respected historian, didn’t fit my image of that formidable leader. Weir certainly knows her subject, but I preferred this woman as described in Weir’s biography, The Life of Elizabeth I.
Well, as the name implies, this is sort of a romance. That’s not a genre I particularly care for, so maybe that’s my problem. I’ve read a couple of Weir’s other novels — one about the young Elizabeth (The Lady Elizabeth) and another about Lady Jane Grey (Innocent Traitor) — and enjoyed them very much, especially the latter.
Focusing on Elizabeth’s long romance with Lord Robert Dudley, alongside marriage negotiations with various European princes, was just too narrow a picture to suit me. Her rule was complicated, successful, and long. It probably wouldn’t have been any of those if she had married.
I read this book concurrent with Weir’s Mary Queen of Scots and the Murder of Lord Darnley, and was gobsmacked by the unique difficulties these female rulers faced. Everyone wanted them to get married (to produce heirs and because “a mere woman needed the advice of a man”). However, any choice would lead to disaster. Whether Catholic or Protestant, foreign or home-grown, as soon as a likely mate was identified the opposing factions went into overtime trying to stop the proposed marriage.
Elizabeth I used this situation to her advantage, stringing along multiple royal suitors in order to keep her country safe and prosperous. Mary Queen of Scotts didn’t fare so well.
Weir’s novel certainly showcases Elizabeth’s fears regarding any marital alliance, but I missed not having the rest of her story.
A Little Plot:
Elizabeth I and Lord Robert Dudley knew each other since their youth. Their mutual passion is strong, but marriage to Dudley could be a disaster for her for a number of reasons, starting with the number of traitors found in his family tree.
For more about Alison Weir, her novels, and her non-fiction writing, cluck here.