Killing Commendatore

By Haruki Murakami

The Short Take:

The meandering plot of this novel included many intriguing threads. Unfortunately they never really wove together. That’s not to say the journey wasn’t interesting, but ultimately it did disappoint this reader.


It’s quite possible I’m simply not intellectual enough to appreciate this work by the highly respected Murakami.  I’ve enjoyed other books by him but this one not so much. It had plenty of elements to engage you, from the finding a hidden artistic masterpiece to a bell that rings in the night… from underground. Mystical elements, characters with hidden motives, creative gridlock and renewal–these are but a few of the components Murakami includes. However, he also spends a great deal of time describing people’s clothes, the menus for solitary meals, and other mundane details. Of course, this heightens the contrast to surreal occurrences in the novel but it also bogs down the storytelling.

But I was still enjoying the read. Until the end.

There was so much rich material, including the physical manifestation of “Idea,” a portrait that reveals a person’s inner self, the disappearance and reappearance of items, and a journey reminiscent of the hero’s quest, as well as previously mentioned points. However, when I reached the end (which I won’t divulge) I was deeply disappointed. Where I was anticipating something that brought together the mysteries and other-worldly parts of the plot it never happened. In fact the resolution to the major crisis of the book was so ordinary it had me saying, “Really?”

Murakami set me up, but then he let me down.

By the way, this novel is supposedly an “epic homage to The Great Gatsby.” While that book was referenced I did not see much relationship. Again, that’s probably my lack.

A Little Plot:

The wife of an unnamed first-person narrator tells him she is seeing another and wants a divorce. After a wandering and lengthy road trip, he is given the opportunity to live in the former home of a famed Japanese artist. Here he hopes to reinvent his own artistic style. But many things intervene.

For more about Haruki Murakami click here.


Be Sociable, Share!
Enter your e-mail address to receive notifications when there are new posts

Leave a Reply


    Want to be notified when there is a new post? Sign up to the RSS feeds below
  • Entries


January 2019
« Dec   Feb »