There There
Tuesday, July 24th, 2018
By Tommy Orange
The Short Take:
This is possibly the most powerful debut novel I’ve ever read. It explores the interrelated lives of a dozen Urban Native Americans living in Oakland, California, the community where Orange himself grew up.
Why?
The title comes from a Gertrude Stein quote about Oakland after she revisited her childhood home, “There is no there there.” This was not dismissive but a reference to the fact that everything had changed, becoming unrecognizable. Native Americans living in big cities often struggle to recognize themselves. Their traditions can seem anachronistic. Their lives are often filled with obstacles. Their history is written in blood.
Orange’s book gives a brief recounting of that tragic history, delivered in a wry voice yet devastating to read. The stories of his 12 protagonists are also devastating: alcoholism, violence, defeat. But there is also hope, love, and passion. You care about them all, want a better life for them, and pray they survive the upcoming powwow. Yeah, you know early on that something will happen there and it won’t be good.
It’s an incredible, exceptional, challenging book. Everyone should read it.
A Little Plot:
There are many plots and subplots in this dense novel. However, all paths seem to lead to the Big Oakland Powwow taking place at the coliseum.